Which is better for astrophotography: crop sensor or full frame?

2 years 2 months ago #523461 by ShutterPal
A buddy and I have attended a couple astrophotography meetups and thinking about jumping in.  

Can one of you help with this "discussion" we are having this morning.  

Which is a better camera sensor for astrophotography:  full frame or crop?  


Photo Comments

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

2 years 2 months ago #523463 by effron
Usually a full frame will handle noise better, so it gets my vote.....

Why so serious?
Photo Comments

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

2 years 1 week ago #530228 by garyrhook
It's a pointless issue, because it avoids the relevant parameters.

1) Focal length. Longer is better. Always.

2) Sensor quality. That varies, and newer sensors, even the smaller ones, can evince better results than older, larger ones.

3) Sensor size. You need to understand resolution of the image area. My FX sensor, at 24MP, can be used to shoot in DX mode. Guess what? The DX area is exactly 16MP, the same size and resolution as the sensor in my DX body. Math and geometry explain this, but I won't bore you.

The difference? The FX sensor is newer and of higher quality in low light situations. Therefore, I will use it. And I won't put it in DX mode. Why throw away perfectly good data?

Quit worrying about view angle. Worry about focal length and resolution/quality/performance of the sensor. Newer full frame will almost always win.


Photo Comments

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

802.3K

205K

1.62M

  • Facebook

    802,251 / Likes

  • Twitter

    205,000 / Followers

  • Google+

    1,620,816 / Followers

Latest Reviews

nikon d3500 vs canon t7 review, Nikon D3500 vs Canon EOS Rebel T7, Nikon D3500 vs Canon EOS Rebel T7 price, Nikon D3500 vs Canon EOS Rebel T7 body, Nikon D3500 vs Canon EOS Rebel T7 specs, Nikon D3500 vs Canon EOS Rebel T7 lenses

Jun 24, 2019

In this Panasonic G95 review, learn why this APS-C mirrorless camera is a great choice for both photographers and videographers that want a high-quality camera on a budget.

Jun 19, 2019

In this Leica Q review, we take a look at one of the premier compact digital cameras on the market, including its specs, design, build quality, and price.

Jun 17, 2019

If you want to upgrade your camera without spending a ton of money, yet don't want to sacrifice quality or features, you might consider the Canon EOS 80D as a top choice.

Jun 13, 2019

Forum Top Posters

Latest Articles

The Syrp Genie Mini is one of my favorite camera accessories, but now that the Syrp Genie Mini II is out with many all-new features, I think it's time to upgrade.

Jun 25, 2019

Screenshot from YouTube video Giant squid are notoriously difficult to photograph. For one thing, they live really, really far underwater. For another,...

Jun 24, 2019

With these landscape photography techniques, you'll learn a few pointers for getting the best shots, no matter what kind of landscape you're exploring.

Jun 24, 2019

nikon d3500 vs canon t7 review, Nikon D3500 vs Canon EOS Rebel T7, Nikon D3500 vs Canon EOS Rebel T7 price, Nikon D3500 vs Canon EOS Rebel T7 body, Nikon D3500 vs Canon EOS Rebel T7 specs, Nikon D3500 vs Canon EOS Rebel T7 lenses

Jun 24, 2019

Not sure if a camera bag or a camera backpack is right for you? In this camera bag vs. camera backpack comparison, learn about the pros and cons of each.

Jun 20, 2019

If your photos are too dark, learn how to fix underexposed photos using this quick and simple three-step process. It takes just a few moments, but the results can be spectacular!

Jun 20, 2019

If you're ready to have beautiful prints made, be sure to consult these 8 canvas printing tips so you know what you need to do (and what you need to look for in a canvas printing company) to get the best results.

Jun 20, 2019

The new Synology DiskStation DS419slim is the perfect NAS for photographers thanks to its small, lightweight design and photography-friendly features.

Jun 20, 2019