Upgrading from 5D MK1 -> EOS R??

1 month 4 weeks ago #640526 by wickerman123
Hi,

For years I've been using a hand-me-down 5D MK1 that my dad bought when it first released.

The camera is still going strong but I'm really starting to get frustrated with it's dated features - my phone manages to focus faster and produce cleaner images. The poor ISO performance particularly frustrates me - taking pictures while on the move or of something moving like a dog is difficult with really slow AF and shooting at anything above ISO 200 start to introduce some horrible noise if the shutter speed is quick.

I've got 3 EF Lenses (used to have more but 2 mysteriously went missing in a removals van, £2k down the drain for my dad.)

I have about £3k saved up so I was looking at the EOS R and while I understand it's an astronomical leap from an OG 5D, all the hate being flung towards that camera has me concerned that I might get buyers regret a few months down the line when Canon inevitably releases another iteration. While I know 3 lenses isn't a lot, and to some switching to Sony would be recommended, I don't have a lot of money to start buying more lenses so I'd rather just stick with what I have for now. (I've been saving up for a while now)

I know the EOS RP is cheaper but the horrible distortion in the video mode looks completely unusable. 


Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

1 month 3 weeks ago #641347 by Robert Chen
The EOS RP isn't getting good ratings.  I'd stick with the EOS R, you'll spend more $$, however it's a better camera.  

Nikon D300 24-70mm f2.8
70-200mm f2.8
50mm f1.4 & 50mm f1.8
105mm f2.8
2 SB800

Photo Comments
The following user(s) said Thank You: wickerman123

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

1 month 2 weeks ago #641863 by Roy Wilson
You're better off going with a Sony or Nikon Z if you want a mirrorless.  Or upgrade to 5D Mark IV.  The R isn't good reviews as Canon took too many short cuts on it.  

Canon 5D Mark II, 30D, 40D, 50 1.2L, 16-35 2.8L Mark II, 24-105 4L IS, 24-70 2.8L, 70-200 2.8L IS, 85 1.8, 4 x 580 EX(II)
Photo Comments

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

1 month 2 weeks ago #641943 by garyrhook
You have a modest budget. Why are you considering bleeding edge products? Unless you like being an early adopter, and can assume the associated risk, you are far better off sticking with a DSLR at this time.

Look at a more modern full frame body, even used. It will be lightyears ahead of the mk I (which was a horrible camera, IMHO...) A $700 APC-S Nikon body will run circles around that.

There are lots of options available to you. The EOS R shouldn't be among them.


Photo Comments

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

1 month 1 week ago #642949 by Ontherocks

garyrhook wrote: You have a modest budget. Why are you considering bleeding edge products? Unless you like being an early adopter, and can assume the associated risk, you are far better off sticking with a DSLR at this time.

Look at a more modern full frame body, even used. It will be lightyears ahead of the mk I (which was a horrible camera, IMHO...) A $700 APC-S Nikon body will run circles around that.

There are lots of options available to you. The EOS R shouldn't be among them.


+1 very good advice.  


Photo Comments

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

1 month 1 week ago #643226 by garyrhook

Ontherocks wrote:

garyrhook wrote: You have a modest budget. Why are you considering bleeding edge products? Unless you like being an early adopter, and can assume the associated risk, you are far better off sticking with a DSLR at this time.

Look at a more modern full frame body, even used. It will be lightyears ahead of the mk I (which was a horrible camera, IMHO...) A $700 APC-S Nikon body will run circles around that.

There are lots of options available to you. The EOS R shouldn't be among them.


+1 very good advice.  


I forgot to add "in my not so humble opinion." My bad.


Photo Comments

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

1 month 3 days ago #643788 by Coolbanana
The EOS R is an excellent camera- anyone who says different is too focussed upon irrelevant specification details that give no more than a psychological advantage to those whose photography skills need the 'boost' of at least thinking they have the 'best' tool or who are being petty over the omission of a specific feature most do not need. 

I'm no Pro but I am friends with a few who are producing fantastic images from the EOS R; wildlife, landscapes and portraits. With the new RF35 it is a wonderful street and travel camera. 

Wedding photographers who feel they must have dual card slots have a good reason to wait for that feature, as do Sports and Action photographers who need faster FPS. Everyone else will be just fine. 

It is comical when people compare one camera to another and cite a 'winner' but cannot ever get to the level of photography either camera is truly capable of. Camera's have reached a point whereby they all are generally great in the hands of a competent photographer. 

When choosing a brand, look beyond just the body to the lenses - the whole system. Also the ergonomics, how it feels in the hand, the feature-set, does it match your preferred work-flow. These are far more important than the whinges of a couple of Pro's because their specific line was not catered for with this initial release or pixel-peepers who spend more time salivating over gear and its ultimate specifications than actually taking images and enjoying them. 

Personally, having tried the EOS R, I bought one. I then sold my 5DIV and 7DII, they did not produce 'better' pictures and were redundant because I preferred the R in terms of ergonomics, handling, work-flow and size. 


Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

1 month 2 days ago #643908 by wickerman123
I ended up going for the EOS R. I've been using that 5D for 12 years so I was looking for something that would last another 12 at least - I wasn't going to go for Nikon with an APC-S, I'd rather have stuck with the 5D!

EOS R + 24-105 was a bitter pill to swallow but I as a I said, I'm in it for the long run. So far it has reinvigorated my love of photography, it's such a joy to shoot with and doesn't at all frustrate me like the ageing 5D did.

Definitely got my eyes on that RF 35mm, would have gone for it had I not had a 50mm that just about does the job.


Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

3 days 22 hours ago #647768 by Tim Dordeck
So it's been a month, how do you like the EOS R? 


Photo Comments

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

802.3K

205K

1.62M

  • Facebook

    802,251 / Likes

  • Twitter

    205,000 / Followers

  • Google+

    1,620,816 / Followers

Latest Reviews

In this Panasonic Lumix ZS200 review, learn why it is one of the best bridge cameras and one of the best travel camera options on the market today.

Jun 12, 2019

In this Olympus OM-D E-M10 Mark III review, learn why this little micro four thirds camera is such a good buy in 2019.

Jun 06, 2019

FujiFilm just dropped the highest-resolution mirrorless camera to date, the 102-megapixel GFX100. In this FujiFilm GFX100 review, we take a look at all the essential specs of this game-changing camera.

May 29, 2019

In the Canon 5D Mark IV vs Canon 6D Mark II, which one wins? In this comparison review, learn about the essential specs, features, pricing, and more, of these Canon cameras.

May 27, 2019

Forum Top Posters

Latest Articles

It's been about a month since I got the Peak Design Travel Tripod. I was impressed out of the gate, and after a few weeks of use, I'm even more impressed now!

Jun 14, 2019

Photographing Oregon should be on any serious landscape photographer's bucket list, as it offers a wide range of breathtaking landscapes, from waterfalls to soaring mountains, coastlines to high deserts.

Jun 14, 2019

Via NASA Beam me up, Scottie! A dune shaped like the famous Star Trek logo was just discovered by NASA on the surface of Mars, and even William Shatner...

Jun 14, 2019

Ever wondered what the perfect blend of video and photos would look like? Fujifilm thinks its an instant photo with audio capabilities. And everyone is...

Jun 13, 2019

Growing up I always wanted to be a National Geographic photographer. Their lives seemed so glamorous, filled with many thanks for their contributions to the...

Jun 13, 2019

In this tutorial, learn a few basic steps and general guidelines that will help you learn how to improve black and white fine art photography.

Jun 13, 2019

In this Panasonic Lumix ZS200 review, learn why it is one of the best bridge cameras and one of the best travel camera options on the market today.

Jun 12, 2019

There's plenty of Fujifilm X-Pro 3 rumors floating around, including the assumption that the camera will be released later this year. Get the scoop on what to expect from Fuji's new X-Pro 3.

Jun 12, 2019