Cropping Body Parts- What to do?

12 years 8 months ago #130138 by Monitor Boy
I have heard that you shouldn't crop at the joint. I have also seen peoples pictures get ripped apart for cropping a limb mid-shaft, no where near a joint.

I ran across pictures taken from ANTM. A lot of times they have their images cropped right at a joint or in the middle of the limb. I, for sure, am not one to C&C a photographer from a pretty popular TV show and one who is professional and shoots internationally. So if they are doing it, Where is the line? What is the "golden rule".

I have included a link to a few photos from ANTM that describe what I am talking about.

img1.tvloop.com/img/showpics/eb/a4/l3491849a0000_1_31954.jpg
www.poptower.com/images/db/1430/450/500/jaslene-gonzalez.jpg
images.buddytv.com/usrimages/usr165/165_antm11_sheena4.jpg


,
12 years 8 months ago #130142 by Baydream
There are "purist" who believe in following "every" "rule" of photography. Thousands of great photographs break these "rules".
Just because people are on television does not always make them right. It simply makes them "visible". We may developed a culture that promotes publicity over quality.
Take them, and ALL critiques, with a grain of salt (or in some cases, a whole shaker full).

Shoot, learn and share. It will make you a better photographer.
fineartamerica.com/profiles/john-g-schickler.html?tab=artwork

Photo Comments
,
12 years 8 months ago #130143 by Tgauge9
I do not think that there is no "golden rule" on where to crop out limbs. I think it is personal preference. Also these photos are more fashion, they are trying to sell something.


,
12 years 8 months ago #130155 by cod
I'm very conscious of the "not cropping at a joint" rule and always experiment with it when cropping people shots but ultimately I go with what looks best to me. Most of the time that does end up being when I avoid a joint, but not always. It's a useful guideline but not a rule. Sometimes, too, we are limited by the finished product. If, for example the end product must be an 8x10" print, then our cropping options are limited a little.

Chris O'Donoghue
Winnipeg, Canada
codonoghue.prosite.com

,
12 years 8 months ago #130177 by Jamie
I agree...general rules work well, but not always for every photo. I think you have to eyeball the finished product and if it seems "odd" where you've cropped, give it another try.

For example, the only image that seemed off to me that you shared was the second one. And, it's where it crops at the tope...cutting off a bitt of the head and fingers. To me, in this photo, I would left the full head and fingers in, and cropped more from the legs. 1) I don't care about his shorts, 2) cropping a little closer to her (cutting the legs down) may feel sexier, 3) I'm drawn first to their faces, so the cropping here seems off-set...

But again, personal opinion here. Most importantly, I'd say, don't be afraid to crop...as it could make a boring photo look amazing! :)

PhotographyTalk Users enjoy 15% OFF at www.photobacks.com !
Use: PHT843 at checkout!

,
12 years 8 months ago #130472 by SJM

Jamie@Photobacks wrote: I agree...general rules work well, but not always for every photo. I think you have to eyeball the finished product and if it seems "odd" where you've cropped, give it another try.

For example, the only image that seemed off to me that you shared was the second one. And, it's where it crops at the tope...cutting off a bitt of the head and fingers. To me, in this photo, I would left the full head and fingers in, and cropped more from the legs. 1) I don't care about his shorts, 2) cropping a little closer to her (cutting the legs down) may feel sexier, 3) I'm drawn first to their faces, so the cropping here seems off-set...

But again, personal opinion here. Most importantly, I'd say, don't be afraid to crop...as it could make a boring photo look amazing! :)


+1

Country guy living in the big Apple!
Photo Comments
,

817.3K

241K

  • Facebook

    817,251 / Likes

  • Twitter

    241,000 / Followers

  • Google+

    1,620,816 / Followers

Latest Reviews

The Olympus Pen E-P7 is an affordable micro four thirds mirrorless camera with 4K video capabilities, a 20.3MP sensor, and 121 focus points, making it a solid entry-level camera for beginners.

May 13, 2024

The Panasonic G9 II is a 25.2-megapixel micro four thirds camera with numerous features that make it punch out of its weight class, like 779 AF points, 5.8K video, and weather sealing.

May 10, 2024

The Fujifilm XT5 is a 40MP mirrorless camera capable of 6.2K video at 30p. With those specs, it’s an ideal choice for photographers needing a camera to pull double duty for imaging and video.

Apr 25, 2024

The Canon EOS R100 is an entry-level mirrorless camera introduced in 2023. But just because it’s an entry-level camera doesn’t mean it’s a bare-bones camera. Find out why in this review!

Apr 22, 2024
Get 600+ Pro photo lessons for $1

Forum Top Posters

Latest Articles

The best photography jobs right now are a mix of tried-and-true gigs like wedding photography and new jobs highlighting AI’s capabilities, travel, and videography.

May 15, 2024

The Olympus Pen E-P7 is an affordable micro four thirds mirrorless camera with 4K video capabilities, a 20.3MP sensor, and 121 focus points, making it a solid entry-level camera for beginners.

May 13, 2024

Starting a photography business is one thing; sustaining your business over a long period of time is another. Use the tips in this professional photography guide to build something with longevity!

May 13, 2024

The Panasonic G9 II is a 25.2-megapixel micro four thirds camera with numerous features that make it punch out of its weight class, like 779 AF points, 5.8K video, and weather sealing.

May 10, 2024

Cinematic photography is an interesting genre that combines photographic and videographic skills along with effective storytelling techniques. The result? Highly impactful images!

May 09, 2024

Newborn photography requires skill, the right gear, and a lot of patience. This beginner’s guide discusses critical topics that will help you be more prepared for before, during, and after the shoot.

May 08, 2024

To fill the frame means to expand the footprint of the subject in your shot. Get in close, zoom in, crop the image, or use other techniques to bring the subject to the forefront.

May 06, 2024

With these simple yet effective beginner photography tips, you can avoid some of the common mistakes beginners make and get improved results with your images.

May 06, 2024